Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Did you miss your activation email


News: - Make sure you know the Forum Rules and Guidelines

Also check out these related sites:

Author Topic: I still don't understand the lists of “Best guitarists”  (Read 2288 times)

OfflineTol´83

  • Guitar George
  • Your hands are cold but your lips are warm
  • Posts: 13
  • Registered: September 2024
I still don't understand the lists of “Best guitarists”
« on: October 03, 2024, 10:15:54 AM »
I know that this topic has been discussed many times before but I think it is good to bring it up from time to time, especially for the possible new generations that read this forum.
I really don't understand how anyone who listens to the Dire Straits discography can doubt that Mark should be at least among the top five guitarists in history in any list (for me #1 without a doubt). I find it laughable the place they put him in. Especially, if you're a guitarist, you realize this. Earlier I was re-listening to Lady Writer and even without wanting to, I came to the same conclusion. I don't even choose to think about it. The complication, intensity, execution, imagination and cleanness of his phrasing is practically unmatched. I personally don't care where he is placed, but anyone who doesn't understand and read these lists believes what they say.

Real Betis Balompié

Offlinequizzaciously

  • Brother in Arms
  • ********
  • Pavel Fomenkov
  • Posts: 4573
  • Location: Saint Petersburg
  • Registered: April 2016
Re: I still don't understand the lists of “Best guitarists”
« Reply #1 on: October 03, 2024, 12:01:48 PM »
I know "underrated" is an overused word, but Mark is an underrated guitar player, no doubt about it, and nobody can prove me otherwise. Not only did he manage to establish the sound that is truly recognisable from a single note, but he did it without any sophisticated equipment, and not only that, he used it in the context of hundreds of his songs/riffs. For the amount of creativity, beauty and fun he brought to the table in the guitar world, he deserves very high positions in whatever lists. It doesn't even matter if he stole this from J. J. Cale or this from Chet Atkins. And so what? Who cares? You try to steal it from Mark and I'll watch how far you'll go.

I think somebody said the guitar is an instrument that is the easiest to play badly and hardest to master. Once you realise how damn hard it is to play like Mark, everybody else pales in comparison. Another problem with these lists is that they lack a million players from genres other than "rock". There are monster jazz, country, folk, and metal players. I generally hate any lists and can't care less about them, but the underrated nature of Mark's music bothers me, that's why I do what I do.

Of course, all this "underrateness" is actually exactly what Mark wants. I'm 100% sure if he wanted it, had more exposure, and pursued this goal in the first place, he'd be regarded as one of the greats. The problem is he doesn't want it, and so naturally, he is either getting forgotten or underrated. Number 100 or something on the stupid list of the greatest guitar players is pretty fair in this light. I bet he'd be more happy not to be there at all.

Offlinedustyvalentino

  • Not Quite The Movie Star
  • Founder
  • THE Sultan of Swing
  • *********
  • Posts: 7189
  • Location: Donkeytown
  • Registered: August 2008
Re: I still don't understand the lists of “Best guitarists”
« Reply #2 on: October 03, 2024, 01:01:15 PM »
They are very easy to understand.

They are clickbait.
"You can't polish a doo-doo" - Mark Knopfler

OfflineRolo

  • Camerado
  • ***
  • i tend to be, sometimes, acid
  • Posts: 476
  • Location: Lisbon
  • Registered: August 2018
Re: I still don't understand the lists of “Best guitarists”
« Reply #3 on: October 03, 2024, 02:58:58 PM »
They are very easy to understand.

They are clickbait.

LOL!!!
99% of all internet content is clickbait.
Subtitles like:
- I'll tell you who is the best...
- Eat overcoocked meat after midnight is good because..
- The worst drummer in my opinion is...

This kind o subs are on almost everything on YT.
It's the same about editorials on News Portals.

Since computers have been able to process the amount of data to generate deep statistcs, EVERYTHING went to median.

And people are innocent enought to ensure that the 'click bait' will be clicked.

Offlinequizzaciously

  • Brother in Arms
  • ********
  • Pavel Fomenkov
  • Posts: 4573
  • Location: Saint Petersburg
  • Registered: April 2016
Re: I still don't understand the lists of “Best guitarists”
« Reply #4 on: October 03, 2024, 03:16:12 PM »
Don't get me started on clickbait... I HATE IT, as any other YouTuber:



I tried to use the clickbait title a couple of times, and it generated 10x more clicks and views, everything else barely gets any views. Luckily for me, I don't care. But I could generate a lot of views and revenue should I opt for stupid titles and thumbnails.

To be honest, the more clickbaity the title and thumbnail are, the more likely I'll get past it. My #1 top pick for worst YT videos is somebody with a sad face and something like "I NEED TO TELL YOU THIS", and in the video itself, it's the stupidest, simplest excuse for doing something. Pathetic.

On the other hand, you still sometimes get videos like this in your feed, which are honest, straight to the point, and not clickbaity. This man died and this was his farewell message:


OfflineChris W

  • Dire Straits drummer
  • Camerado
  • *
  • i am new on here, be gentle
  • Posts: 367
  • Registered: February 2022
Re: I still don't understand the lists of “Best guitarists”
« Reply #5 on: October 03, 2024, 03:49:00 PM »
Lists of top 'anything' are highly subjective.
There are dozens of guitarists equal to Mark. Not saying Mark isn't amazing and worthy of every plaudit he gets....
But off the top of my head -
John McLaughlin
Jeff Beck
Pat Metheny
Paco Di Lucia
Andres Segovia
Jimi Hendrix
Eric Clapton
Lee Ritenour
Larry Carlton
Steve Lukather
Joe Pass
Ry Cooder
Frank Zappa
Buddy Guy
BB King
Stevie Ray Vaughan
Nile Rogers
And more...

OfflineRolo

  • Camerado
  • ***
  • i tend to be, sometimes, acid
  • Posts: 476
  • Location: Lisbon
  • Registered: August 2018
Re: I still don't understand the lists of “Best guitarists”
« Reply #6 on: October 03, 2024, 04:00:59 PM »
Lists of top 'anything' are highly subjective.
There are dozens of guitarists equal to Mark. Not saying Mark isn't amazing and worthy of every plaudit he gets....
But off the top of my head -
John McLaughlin
Jeff Beck
Pat Metheny
Paco Di Lucia
Andres Segovia
Jimi Hendrix
Eric Clapton
Lee Ritenour
Larry Carlton
Steve Lukather
Joe Pass
Ry Cooder
Frank Zappa
Buddy Guy
BB King
Stevie Ray Vaughan
Nile Rogers
And more...

Now we are talking.
So here is my:

Allan Holdsworth
John McLaughlin
Jeff Beck
BB King
Michael Landau
Wes Mongomery
Jimi Hendrix
Peter Green
Eric Clapton
Steve Lukather
Robben Ford
Mark Knopfler
David Gilmour
SRV
Derek Trucks
Tommy Emmanuel
Steve Morse

Except for Allan and John, there is no rank on my list.  ;D


OfflineRobson

  • Brother in Arms
  • ********
  • Posts: 4358
  • Location: PL
  • Registered: July 2009
Re: I still don't understand the lists of “Best guitarists”
« Reply #7 on: October 03, 2024, 04:16:44 PM »
On a quick note, my favorite 10:

MK
David Gilmour
Andy Latimer
Steve Rothery
Steve Hackett
Eric Clapton
Snowy White
J.J. Cale
Chet Atkins
Nick Barrett
I know the way I can see by the moonlight
Clear as the day
Now come on woman, come follow me home

Offlinequizzaciously

  • Brother in Arms
  • ********
  • Pavel Fomenkov
  • Posts: 4573
  • Location: Saint Petersburg
  • Registered: April 2016
Re: I still don't understand the lists of “Best guitarists”
« Reply #8 on: October 03, 2024, 05:06:42 PM »
Yeah, after all, your list of favourites is highly dependent on your influences, whether you're a musician or not, and what kind of music you listen to if you are a musician. Musician's Musicians often tend to get low on lists as they are not as interesting to the general audience or their talent or impact may be not as obvious. In fact, Mark Knopfler himself might be a musician's musician as he barely appears in lists of best. However, WHEN ASKED, guitarists will say, "Oh, yes, this guy is the best!".

My Top 10 at the moment (I'm a classical guitar player)...

John Williams
Chet Atkins
Roland Dyens
Luiz Bonfá
Tommy Emmanuel
Django Reinhardt
BB King
Kazuhito Yamashita
Trey Hensley
Hank Marvin

OfflineTol´83

  • Guitar George
  • Your hands are cold but your lips are warm
  • Posts: 13
  • Registered: September 2024
Re: I still don't understand the lists of “Best guitarists”
« Reply #9 on: October 03, 2024, 05:08:16 PM »
Once you realise how damn hard it is to play like Mark, everybody else pales in comparison.

For me, this is the crux of the matter.
Real Betis Balompié

OfflineRobson

  • Brother in Arms
  • ********
  • Posts: 4358
  • Location: PL
  • Registered: July 2009
Re: I still don't understand the lists of “Best guitarists”
« Reply #10 on: October 03, 2024, 05:11:41 PM »
Yeah, after all, your list of favourites is highly dependent on your influences, whether you're a musician or not, and what kind of music you listen to if you are a musician. Musician's Musicians often tend to get low on lists as they are not as interesting to the general audience or their talent or impact may be not as obvious. In fact, Mark Knopfler himself might be a musician's musician as he barely appears in lists of best. However, WHEN ASKED, guitarists will say, "Oh, yes, this guy is the best!".

My Top 10 at the moment (I'm a classical guitar player)...

John Williams
Chet Atkins
Roland Dyens
Luiz Bonfá
Tommy Emmanuel
Django Reinhardt
BB King
Kazuhito Yamashita
Trey Hensley
Hank Marvin

Why I forgot about Hank B. Marvin. Thanks quizzaciously :)
I know the way I can see by the moonlight
Clear as the day
Now come on woman, come follow me home

Offlinequizzaciously

  • Brother in Arms
  • ********
  • Pavel Fomenkov
  • Posts: 4573
  • Location: Saint Petersburg
  • Registered: April 2016
Re: I still don't understand the lists of “Best guitarists”
« Reply #11 on: October 03, 2024, 05:32:42 PM »
Once you realise how damn hard it is to play like Mark, everybody else pales in comparison.

For me, this is the crux of the matter.

Playing and singing like Mark Knopfler is difficult in the same way it's difficult to play and sing like Louis Armstrong... It's so difficult it's downright impossible and, if you ask me, pointless. I'm dying from cringe when I see people trying to sing like Louis Armstrong, and the same with Mark Knopfler. Likewise, nobody would place Louis on lists of best singers or trumpet players; he's just this unique, he transcends lists. And everybody loves him!

OfflineRobson

  • Brother in Arms
  • ********
  • Posts: 4358
  • Location: PL
  • Registered: July 2009
Re: I still don't understand the lists of “Best guitarists”
« Reply #12 on: October 03, 2024, 05:49:27 PM »
But "What A Wonderful World" Mark sang beautifully  ;)
I know the way I can see by the moonlight
Clear as the day
Now come on woman, come follow me home

OfflineRolleyway Man

  • Camerado
  • ***
  • Posts: 258
  • Location: Southampton, UK
  • Registered: October 2010
    • Mike’s Musical Musings
Re: I still don't understand the lists of “Best guitarists”
« Reply #13 on: October 03, 2024, 06:28:30 PM »
You’ve all forgotten to mention Lindsey Buckingham. A much overlooked guitarist with phenomenal technical skill. At times he is like three or four guitarists in one.

I agree with Dusty on the ‘best ever’ lists though. Absolute clickbait bollocks and of no use to anyone whatsoever. It’s all a matter of personal taste as to whichever guitarist you prefer over another.

OfflineRolo

  • Camerado
  • ***
  • i tend to be, sometimes, acid
  • Posts: 476
  • Location: Lisbon
  • Registered: August 2018
Re: I still don't understand the lists of “Best guitarists”
« Reply #14 on: October 03, 2024, 06:47:33 PM »
Don't get me started on clickbait... I HATE IT, as any other YouTuber:

Outside been a musician, I am a Data Engineer and since 2011 I work with several Data Science projects since then.
As you know, all this 'trends/clickbaits' are based simply on data analysis.

I'll tell you.
All Data Scientists, Engineers, IA specialysts will be the next public enemies.
Yes, we a guilty on many things. However, there is a lot of things that happens simply because people are stupid enought to not understand 'what to learn' from analytics

 

© 2024 amarkintime.org
This is an unofficial website dedicated to Mark Knopfler developed and maintained by fans.
Top banner design by Dutchessy.
This theme is based on the SMF theme Carbonate by Bloc.
SMF 2.0.15 | SMF © 2017, Simple Machines
Simple Audio Video Embedder
Simple Audio Video Embedder
Page created in 0.049 seconds with 38 queries.