Unfortunately, "Basil" still does nothing for me and sinks Tracker IMVHO, whereas I love "Back on the Dance Floor". Make of that what you will.
Still haven't made up my mind about "Ahead of the Game", but so far I can't say it impresses me like "Good On You Son" did, which I really felt was a breath of fresh air at the time (though I find the radio edit missing some great bits now).
I think one could fall in love with Basil (the song, not the man) by just reading the lines like "Poets have to eat as well", "What he wouldn't give just to walk out today / To have time to think about time", "Bury all joy / Put the poems in sacks / And bury me here with the hacks", "Basil puts on his old duffel and scarf / And goes out into the dark."
I mean just reading this gives me chills, and I'm not even a native English speaker. But on top of that, you get Mark's beautiful vocals, usual guitar brilliance, and perfect production. I can't understand how somebody can not like a song like this. It's incredibly atmospheric and hands down one of the best songs on the Tracker album, if not the best. Maybe you are just not a fan of slow ballads. If you are, then give it another shot.
"Back on the Dance Floor" is also a great song, but its greatness lies definitely not in words, more like in landscapes painted with the music, with this very Bryan Ferry/Steely Dan sound, like something recorded in the mid-80s, and this backing vocals and effects. So Basil is more like a song for the heart, and Dance Floor a song for the body if it makes sense. Same with "Ahead of the Game"... It's catchy, uptempo, moves your body, like a single should.