Roger Waters in Lyon

[JF]

Posts amended 

ah ah nice translation 

[Dutchessy]

I came across a lot of comments on youtube, about Roger Waters seems to lip sync almost everything each concert.
Is is common knowledge? Did you know? And is it true? When you google it, there are a lot of topics about it.

I enjoyed the show anyway, he wasn't 'singing' a lot after all, so i don't really care, but i'm curious. There even was a bass player behind him the whole concert  So i wonder, did he played bass, or was that 'off' as well?

[Jules]

When he sings he does some screaming to emphasise parts that if they are synched, he's quite good.

Also his bass parts are quite strong and with a nerve that is clear what he's doing and what does the other player.

Me and my friends also commented that many parts of the concert could be easily playback but some singing parts and also some instrumental parts are clearly played live.

[ds1984]

Definitively, Roger is using prerecorded vocal tape.

That does not means that he is singing full playback but at least some part are.

To get the absolute answer is to watch the "Live in Rio Liboa" broadcast.
Pre recorded Roger is on the right channel while live Roger is center.