sorry disagree. I find live version too much filled. Too much "big sound", and the steinberger....beeerk !
the studio version is perfect for me, doesn't sound "empty" at all.
I prefer this songs WITHOUT a rhythm guitar : ride across the river, one world, brothers in arms, money for nothing.
I think that if Mark recorded them without rhyhtm guitar parts, it's because he wanted them sound this way.
Its has a rhythm guitar live, only because the 2nd guitarist couldn't stay without playing.
Well, whether Mark 'wanted' them to sound a certain way is of no relevance for if I or anyone else likes the result. The thing about the live version is not so much that there is a second rhytm guitar, but that Mark emphasizes the rhytm playing during all parts except the solos, which gives the song more drive and force.
It seems that we disagree about this in a general sense, however, because I do prefer songs like BIA with a second guitar and I have often lamented that Mark played less rhytm on that album.
we agree and disagree
I LOVE Mark's rhythm playing, and I think it features most of his fine guitar work : single handed sailor, skateway, southbound again, once upon a time in the west, when it come to you, on way gal, man of peace, cleaning windows, Do Right to Me Baby, etc... and I would love to hear again more ryhtm parts in THIS style (not the KTGC style...)
but, I find his rhythm playing on one world live too sharp, less subtle as he used to do, and too much "drive and force"
I don't like very much when Mark try to sound "rock", "heavy", on guitar (85-93 era)
I think his style suits more to subtle picking, etheral soli, ambient sounds, clean/crunchy tone, etc...
his tone and playing on One wordl is....well ; I don't find it's Mark
and I prefer BIA with only his guitar (Richard's 12-strings part sounds fine, though)