"Division bell" poll : Privateering Super Deluxe Edition

[herlock]

I did buy it, well aware that it was a rip-off, but just didn't how far the rip off would go: I knew about TR missing in the so-called "full concert", I knew about the 5 so-called "live" songs CD not being included.... but I had no idea that the particular sequence I wanted to have officially (a small part of Going Home with Henk B. Marvin in Wembel'85) from the "Live in songs" documentary would be censored...

I think there is also a legal case to fight, this documentary being edited (shall I say: butchered ?) without notice.

[Pottel]

why is this called the division bell poll?
i was expecting Floyd content here!
never do that again

[ds1984]

why is this called the division bell poll?
i was expecting Floyd content here!
never do that again

Because the poll refers to what Pink Floyd's song title is about : choosing between just YES or NO.
So, there is spiritual Floyd content here

This not what you expected however it does not means to be surrogate.

[Jules]

First rule: Don

[Pottel]

you know, there were these semi official division bell boxes back in the days, consisting of an actual bell (shaped box...) so that got my heart pumping...

[ds1984]

you know, there were these semi official division bell boxes back in the days, consisting of an actual bell (shaped box...) so that got my heart pumping...

This?

PINK FLOYD "The Division Bell" (Limited Edition to 2000)

Or this?

Blue Glass Bell

[Pottel]

seen both, but i did mean the first one.
i believe they did it for other albums as well...

[herlock]

why is this called the division bell poll?
i was expecting Floyd content here!
never do that again

Division Bell is -not- Floyd content :p
Or, if it is, then "Amused to Death" should be considered as Floyd content as well :p

[3Strats]

As someone who bought the Get Lucky boxed set for over

[Vesper]

I bought it, offcourse!
but it was a little dissapointing for the price

[JF]

why is this called the division bell poll?
i was expecting Floyd content here!
never do that again

Division Bell is -not- Floyd content :p
Or, if it is, then "Amused to Death" should be considered as Floyd content as well :p

+1
But I know Pottel will disagree

[Pottel]

why is this called the division bell poll?
i was expecting Floyd content here!
never do that again

Division Bell is -not- Floyd content :p
Or, if it is, then "Amused to Death" should be considered as Floyd content as well :p

B.S.
Division bell Is as much Floyd as momentary lap of reason or the final cut.
I can't Stand these "roger is Floyd" comments all the time...

[herlock]

why is this called the division bell poll?
i was expecting Floyd content here!
never do that again

Division Bell is -not- Floyd content :p
Or, if it is, then "Amused to Death" should be considered as Floyd content as well :p

B.S.
Division bell Is as much Floyd as momentary lap of reason or the final cut.
I can't Stand these "roger is Floyd" comments all the time...

I did not say nor meant "roger is floyd" but rather "roger plus Dave is Floyd". I love both really, but I think none of them can claim the legacy alone.
I also said this in a form of a joke, it is not necessary to react so strongly...

[ds1984]

why is this called the division bell poll?
i was expecting Floyd content here!
never do that again

Division Bell is -not- Floyd content :p
Or, if it is, then "Amused to Death" should be considered as Floyd content as well :p

B.S.
Division bell Is as much Floyd as momentary lap of reason or the final cut.
I can't Stand these "roger is Floyd" comments all the time...

If Roger is Floyd, which one is Pink? (sorry could not resist  )

[Jules]

why is this called the division bell poll?
i was expecting Floyd content here!
never do that again

Division Bell is -not- Floyd content :p
Or, if it is, then "Amused to Death" should be considered as Floyd content as well :p

B.S.
Division bell Is as much Floyd as momentary lap of reason or the final cut.
I can't Stand these "roger is Floyd" comments all the time...

If Roger is Floyd, which one is Pink? (sorry could not resist  )

The one that it