OK, so that makes you 1/8 th Italian. I don't know if that counts, but it would explain your sense of humor and justice. (A vendetta
)
As for the records with immediate appeal, I can only argue that all in all, it is a matter of statistics. If you count the number of times you hear a record, or the will to listen after a long time, or whatever. I have the same problem, "spending" the records I like at first listen, but, hands down, I have certainly spent way more time with the easy ones, adding up the times I have listened to them. I have heard like a virgin more times than True love will never fade.
You can have bread everyday, but you can't eat caviar everyday! (OK, I haven't tasted caviar ever, you can replace it with your favorite snack or sweet. Or beer / wine and Champagne)