I'm so glad that I saw the show in Edinburgh and if it does go to London I wouldn't even contemplate going if there is less than one hour's music - far too expensive with train fares, hotels and restaurants to be taken into consideration too!
Actually, having listened to both shows I enjoyed the Edinburgh one more than Chichester - but, of course, I wasn't at the actual Chichester show and musicals are also a visual experience. Chichester was chopped up too much for me and there were far too many reprises and too much talking. Daniel Evans should have watched/listened to the Edinburgh show first imo.
I remember I wanted to answer this post in its day but I don't know why, I didn't! Today I just wake up with one of the new melodies on repeat on my brain, so revisited this thread to read the lyrics of the new first song and noticed...
I think you would had enjoyed this Chichester version because the start was great and put you in the mood because it's a brand new song with a great vibe, with even fire efects and all. It was so surprising and refreshing that it makes you enjoy it from the start and the actors were so good that all flows nicely despite the differences.
Also when you discover that two more songs are musically new made, like "Big Mac" and "Numbers", specially this last one which has a wonderful melody, and it's in the second half, compensate the missing songs in that second half. Actually, even with that extra music in Edinburgh, I remember the second part as weakest than the first, in Chichester that part had less songs and more acting and worked a bit better but despite there were short musical passages here and there, actually reprises of melodies and even sung parts, you really miss some of the numbers.
When it comes to London, which I hope it happens next year, I guess that would be closer to the Chichester version but I also guess (and hope) there would be changes as director Daniel Evans, which I was sitting just beind him, was all the show taking notes, and I think the show I attended was more than a week from first representation. I guess he saw things to improve but that won't be time to do whith the musical already running.
Also London representations would be important as they would set what ends on the CD release of it and I personally don't want to miss it!
And what's more important, it looks like it might be the only chance to attend something MK related live, and also a great chance to see some of you again!