Got to have something

[JF]

of course the song has the same pattern as Muddy Waters' rollin' and tumblin.
But I was listening this morning NHB at Ronnie scott on July 13th 1999, and when I heard "Meet me at the bottom", I think that Mark was rather more inspirated by this song than the Muddy Waters one.
anyway, it's the same pattern, an ususal one in blues music, but the rhythm is closer

[superval99]

of course the song has the same pattern as Muddy Waters' rollin' and tumblin.
But I was listening this morning NHB at Ronnie scott on July 13th 1999, and when I heard "Meet me at the bottom", I think that Mark was rather more inspirated by this song than the Muddy Waters one.
anyway, it's the same pattern, an ususal one in blues music, but the rhythm is closer

"Can't Be Satisfied" is in the same vein too!   

[dmg]

All these kinds of songs sound the same!  That's why they're fun to listen to but have no long-lasting appeal or originality.

[superval99]

All these kinds of songs sound the same!  That's why they're fun to listen to but have no long-lasting appeal or originality.

I believe the first recorded version of Rollin' & Tumblin' was by Hambone Willie Newbern in 1929, so it has survived in all it's various versions very well!      As you say they are fun!   

[JF]

of course the song has the same pattern as Muddy Waters' rollin' and tumblin.
But I was listening this morning NHB at Ronnie scott on July 13th 1999, and when I heard "Meet me at the bottom", I think that Mark was rather more inspirated by this song than the Muddy Waters one.
anyway, it's the same pattern, an ususal one in blues music, but the rhythm is closer

"Can't Be Satisfied" is in the same vein too!   

in the same vein, yes but not exactly the same pattern

rollin, meet me...,and got to have... have exactly the same chords structure, and same rhythm, and same melody too 

So I'd say they are closer than other blues tunes, but of course many blues tunes sounds "the same"

[dmg]

All these kinds of songs sound the same!  That's why they're fun to listen to but have no long-lasting appeal or originality.

I believe the first recorded version of Rollin' & Tumblin' was by Hambone Willie Newbern in 1929, so it has survived in all it's various versions very well!      As you say they are fun!   

Very true and hence very thought provoking because it's basically mediocre imo...

[Stanko]

First sorry because I'm late and backward with the post.
Is there anyone could help me where has he found or what is the picture for this one?
Thank you in advance.

[vgonis]

I did mention this on another post, some time ago. Anyway. Listen to this as well!

[vgonis]

I also mentioned how much alike are the songs "Beyond here lies nothin'" by Bob Dylan  and "All your love" by John Mayall's bluesbreakes.

[Stanko]

Thank you very much.
I will take a look.

[vgonis]

http://www.amarkintime.org/forum/index.php/topic,550.50.html  From a post created by good old dusty, so I was off topic. But near the end you will find the posts mentioned. Also, if you have the time check out the great work of dusty!