T - glad you enjoyed Birdsong.
I think I agree with you about the ending - but a v minor criticism of one of the best British novels in years.
Interesting the Beevor bit. A few months ago I won a signed collection of his called The Antony Beevor Collection (strangely enough!) . Four books - Paris, after the liberation 1944-1949: Crete, the battle and the resistance:Stalingrad : and Berlin, the downfall. All hardback and in a beautiful box. Ashamed to say I haven't started to read them as yet.